The Danger of Partial Obedience
A Sermon
Preached on February 7, 2010, by
The Rev. S. Randall Toms, Ph. D.,
At St. Paul’s Reformed Episcopal Church, Baton Rouge, Louisiana
For Herod feared John, knowing that he was a just man and an holy, and observed him; and when he heard him, he did many things, and heard him gladly. (Mark 6:20)
It’s been a long time since I was addicted to watching soap operas. In my teen-age years I was addicted to a couple of them. Believe it or not, when I was in seminary, I watched one regularly during the lunch break between classes. If you have ever watched the soaps, you know how complicated the relationships can become. People get married, have children, then they get divorced and wind up marrying their brothers-in-law and their sisters-in-law, It gets very difficult to keep straight exactly what category of kinship they have with one another. As complicated as our soaps may be, they are not more complicated than the relationships that existed in the family of Herod the Great. Herod the Great was the ruler of Judea at the time that Jesus was born, the Herod who ordered the slaughter of the Innocents. Herod had many different wives and many children by those different wives. I won’t try to give you a complete genealogy of Herod’s descendants, but for the purposes of our text this morning, let me give you a brief history of the relationships that are relevant. Herod the Great had a son, Antipas, who is the Herod in our text who had John the Baptist executed. Herod the Great had another son, Philip, who lived in Rome and was married to Herodias, the Herodias in our text for today. Herodias was a granddaughter of Herod the Great by one of his many other wives. Herod Antipas went to Rome and convinced Herodias to leave her husband, Philip. She did so, divorced him, and married Herod Antipas. So, Herodias is Herod Antipas’ sister-in-law and niece, and now, wife. It is little wonder then that a prophet like John the Baptist would tell him that he has broken the law of God. As is often the case, Herodias, the wife, is the one who really gets angry with John the Baptist. I can just hear her saying, “Who is he to say that we shouldn’t be married? Who is he who to think that he can rebuke a king and his wife.”
But Herod’s relationship to John the Baptist was rather strange. Though John the Baptist had rebuked him, Herod had a great deal of respect for John. Herodias had tried to convince Herod to kill John the Baptist, but Herod wouldn’t do it. We are told that Herod feared John. It’s an interesting thing how people feel about a real man of God. They may not like him, they may not agree with what he says, but they respect him. They are also a little afraid of him. Sometimes, it’s a kind of superstitious fear. It’s almost as though they consider it bad luck to do something bad to the preacher. Herod probably had just enough of the fear of God in him to worry him that if he did something to John the Baptist, God might pour out his judgment on him. It was difficult not to respect a man like John the Baptist. Here was a man who had lived in the desert as a mark of his dedication and preparation for the service of God. It was obvious that John was no hypocrite. Verse 20 says that Herod knew that John was a just and holy man. The word for just means “righteous.” John was a man who kept the law of the Lord and walked in his way blameless. He was a holy man, a saint, one whom God had set apart to fulfill the special task of preparing the way of the Lord and to make his paths straight. He was not like many of the other religious leaders that Herod knew and had on his payroll. John was a true man of God and didn’t care if rebuking a king would cost him his life. Such a man gains the respect even of those who disagree with him. Herod feared him. This passage also says that Herod observed him. The word translated “observed” means either “to preserve,” or “to ponder.” If we take the meaning to be “preserve,” it means that Herod protected John, though Herodias wanted him dead. If it means “ponder,” we see that though Herod was not willing to be obedient to what John said, he did think a great deal about what John taught.
As a matter of fact, the passage tells us that Herod heard John gladly. I’ve known many men like Herod—men who had very little interest in living godly lives, agreed with very little I had to say, but for some reason loved to hear strong preaching; and the more I got worked up, the more I preached against sin, the better they liked it. Herod must have been something like that. He heard John gladly, even though John told him to his face he was an adulterer. In some ways, Herod was like the stony ground hearer in our Gospel reading for this morning. Jesus said that the stony ground hearer was one who heard the word and received it with “gladness” (Mark 4:16), but because the word does not take root in their lives, they fall away when times of tribulation or persecution come. But perhaps Herod was more like the one who received the word among the thorns. They are the ones who hear the word, but the cares of this world, and the lusts of other things choke the word, and they become unfruitful. Or as Luke puts it, the cares and riches and pleasures of this life, choke the word (Luke 8:14). That would describe Herod perfectly. Herod is a great example of a man who was a hearer of the word, but not a doer of the word, though he “did many things.”
It seems that Herod was willing to put some of John’s teaching into practice. Perhaps Herod even repented of some of his sins. But riches, pleasures, cares, and lusts kept him from making a thorough repentance. He was willing to do many things, but he was not willing to give up his beloved Herodias. Finally came the time when Herodias’ daughter, whom we know as Salome, danced before him. It is here that it was revealed that though Herod was willing to do many things in response to the teaching of John the Baptist, he was still ruled by his lust, particularly his sexual lust. After Salome danced, Herod promised to give her whatever she wished, up to half of his kingdom. If that’s not a man ruled by his lust, I don’t know what is. A man who will give up half of his kingdom to a girl because of a dance is a slave to his passions. But we shouldn’t think it strange or unusual for a man to give up so much because of uncontrollable lust. Haven’t we seen politicians, ministers, and family men give up half their kingdoms and more for much the same reason? These were men who did many things, who in many other areas of their lives were very good men, fulfilling their responsibilities, and keeping some of God’s commandments, but there was one powerful lust that ruled their lives for which they were willing to sacrifice almost everything. Herod is an example of an incomplete repentance—a man, in some ways, wanting to do what was right, but at the same time holding on to his most beloved sin. Because of his unwillingness to obey God completely, we find him willing to kill the man of God, the man that he feared, the man that he knew was a righteous and holy man. He was willing to kill him for the sake of a rash oath he had made to a woman. No doubt, this sinful act resulted in an even further hardening of Herod’s heart, for we find that when Jesus Christ was brought before him, that Herod mocked the Son of God. Herod, who had seen that John was a just and holy man, had now become so hardened that he could not recognize the same in our Lord Jesus Christ. We are told that our Lord Jesus Christ did not say one single word to Herod, which may be the Scripture’s way of saying that Herod’s conscience had been seared with a hot iron, and it was useless to speak to him. This is the kind of hardening that results when we are unwilling to let go of our dearest sins.
Today is Sexagesima Sunday, approximately 60 days before Easter. It is part of our pre-Lenten season where we begin to prepare our hearts for the season of Lent. Our Church calendar had us read this story of Herod on the Tuesday before this Sunday. Herod is a good example of the person who will start out to live a righteous life, but will ultimately give in to the pleasures of the world. How different he is from the Apostle Paul. In our Epistle Reading for today, we find the great apostle who describes his life as
…in labours more abundant, in stripes above measure, in prisons more frequent, in deaths oft. Of the Jews five times received I forty stripes save one. Thrice was I beaten with rods, once was I stoned, thrice I suffered shipwreck, a night and a day I have been in the deep; in journeyings often, in perils of waters, in perils of robbers, in perils by mine own countrymen, in perils by the heathen, in perils in the city, in perils in the wilderness, in perils in the sea, in perils among false brethren; in weariness and painfulness, in watchings often, in hunger and thirst, in fastings often, in cold and nakedness. (II Cor. 11:23-26)
Paul represents that soil that received the word of God and brought forth fruit. Herod allowed what other people thought of him to rule his life, so much so that he was willing to kill John and support the decision to kill Jesus. Paul did not let beatings, prisons, and many other kinds of suffering deter him from following Christ, and as a result, he bore much fruit. Herod allowed the lusts of his flesh to choke the word of God. Paul was willing to turn his back on all the pleasures of this life if only he might serve Christ and spread his gospel.
During this season of Lent, like Herod, we will probably “do many things.” We will realize that we are doing some things that we shouldn’t do, and we will repent. But will we stop short? Will we be willing to give up that Herodias in our life? Will we be willing to stand firm for righteousness and holiness even when the lusts of the flesh lure us away? Alexander MacLaren described Herod in this way:
Herod was a weak-willed man, drawn by two stronger natures pulling in opposite directions. So he alternated between lust and purity, between the foul kisses of the temptress at his side and the warnings of the prophet in his dungeon… Thus he staggered along, with religion enough to spoil some of his sinful delights, but not enough to make him give them up…. We do not make up for such cowardly shrinking from doing right by pleasure in the divine word which we are not obeying. Some of us think ourselves good Christians because we assent to truth, and even like to hear it, provided the speaker suit our tastes. Glad hearing only aggravates the guilt of not doing. It is useless to admire John if you keep Herodias.
One of the reasons we fast during the season of Lent is to give us an example of how we need to be in control of our bodies, our appetites that may get out of hand, out of control, and dominate our lives. Lent is a time to strengthen our resolve to overcome those things that lure us from giving Christ first place in our lives. Lent is a time when can show that following Christ is more important to us than yielding to those pleasures which may not be in accordance with God’s will.
During Lent, we are often made painfully aware of these two strong natures pulling in opposite directions. We find in ourselves a desire to obey God, and at the same time, the desire to follow our own desires. Years ago I heard a preacher who said that most people have just enough religion to make them miserable. They have just enough religion to let them know that what they are doing is wrong, but it doesn’t give them enough power to quit. As we examine ourselves during the season of Lent, we often find ourselves miserable because we realize how weak we are when it comes to resisting sin. But Lent is not profitable to us if it only makes us miserable. We must come out of the Lenten season with the power of the resurrected Christ who rose from the dead to deliver us from both the guilt of sin and the power of sin. If the season of Lent does not result in a resolve to truly repent, a resolve to give up even the most darling of our sins, if it does not result in sincere, agonizing prayer to be delivered from all our sins, then, like Herod, our “doing many things” will only result in making us more hardened in our hearts. Nothing hardens us so much as being convicted for our sins, and then refusing to repent of those sins. During this season of Lent, let Herod’s life and hardness of heart stand as a warning to us of the danger of hanging on to the things of this world. Let us set the example of the Apostle Paul before us, who truly meant it when he said, “What is more, I consider everything a loss compared to the surpassing greatness of knowing Christ Jesus my Lord, for whose sake I have lost all things. I consider them rubbish, that I may gain Christ” (Phil. 3:8, NIV). When you see the things of this world, will you be like Herod, or like St. Paul? Will the things of this world be everything, or will you, like St. Paul, see them as rubbish when compared to knowing Christ? With these thoughts in mind, Dean Henry Alford’s prayer that I included in your order of service today is so appropriate. Let this prayer be in our hearts constantly as we enter this season of the year:
O Thou Sower of the good seed in men’s hearts, grant to us that we may not receive it by the wayside, so as speedily to lose it: nor in shallow soil, so as to hear with joy, but, having no root, in time of temptation to fall away: nor among thorns, so that it is choked with cares and riches and pleasures of this life. But break Thou up our fallow soil, that we, receiving Thy seed into good and honest hearts, may keep it, and bring forth fruit unto life everlasting. Save us from a trifling spirit: save us from sudden and passing excitement: save us from an heart divided between the world and Thee. Give us earnestness, strength of purpose, simplicity of faith, warmth of love, that we may inherit the blessing which Thou hast promised to them who are doers as well hearers of Thy word; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.